Company phones or BYOD comes down to tax, security and control
Once you take on staff, the question comes up: do you hand staff company phones, or let them use their own? Letting people bring their own device, usually shortened to BYOD, looks cheaper on day one. Company phones look tidier. The real difference shows up in three places: tax, security and who controls the data.
This guide sets out what HMRC says about the tax on each route, what the National Cyber Security Centre says about the security side, and the costs that hide in between.
It’s general information, not tax advice. Your accountant can tell you how the rules apply to your payroll.
How are company phones taxed?
Company phones are usually the simplest route for tax. HMRC says you don’t have to report anything or pay tax and National Insurance if both of these apply: you provide the employee with only one mobile phone or SIM card, and the phone contract is between your business and the supplier.
There are a few edges to watch:
- More than one phone. HMRC says one of the phones is exempt from paying and reporting, but any other phones count as assets.
- Salary sacrifice. HMRC says you do have to report employees’ mobile phone costs if they are part of a salary sacrifice arrangement.
- The employee’s contract, your money. If the employee arranges the phone but you pay the supplier, HMRC says you must report the cost on form P11D and pay Class 1 National Insurance through payroll.
So the clean version of company phones is one handset or SIM per person, on a contract in the business’s name.
How is BYOD taxed?
With BYOD, the tax depends on what you pay back. HMRC says that if your employee uses their own phone and you reimburse them, you don’t need to report it on a P11D, but you may still have to deduct Class 1 National Insurance and PAYE tax through payroll.
For staff on a monthly tariff, HMRC says you must deduct and pay National Insurance and tax if you reimburse the monthly tariff, or private calls over the tariff’s limit, or both. Business calls over the limit can be reimbursed without National Insurance or tax.
For staff on pay as you go, HMRC says that if you reimburse the employee for business calls, you do not have to deduct and pay any National Insurance or tax.
In practice, chipping in towards someone’s monthly bill is likely to go through payroll. That’s not a reason to avoid BYOD, but it’s a cost to count when you compare it with company phones.
Key takeaways
- One company phone or SIM per person, on a business contract, is exempt from tax and reporting.
- Paying towards a member of staff’s own monthly tariff usually goes through payroll.
- With BYOD, the business owns the work data but not the phone.
- Count support, security and leavers as well as the monthly bill.
What does BYOD mean for security?
The National Cyber Security Centre defines BYOD as employees using their personally owned devices for work purposes. Your organisation owns the corporate data and resources on the phone, but the device itself is the property of the user. How well you can protect that data depends on how much the owner lets you manage the device.
The NCSC lists the challenges, including making sure personally owned devices and their owners comply with company policies and procedures, increased support for a wide range of device types and operating systems, protecting corporate data, protecting corporate infrastructure, protecting the personal privacy of the device owner, and ensuring legal compliance and meeting contractual obligations. It also warns that staff who find a scheme hard to work with may turn to “shadow IT”, their own workarounds, which is likely to increase security risk.
The NCSC says the primary audience for its guidance is large and medium sized organisations, but the questions apply to a five person firm too. If a member of staff leaves, can you remove work email and files from their phone without touching their photos? With company phones, the answer is usually easier, because the business controls the whole device.
Which costs more, company phones or BYOD?
It depends on your team, which is an unhelpful answer, so here’s how to work it out for yours. On the company phones side, add the monthly line cost per person over the contract, any handset cost and any device management tool you’d use. On the BYOD side, add what you’d reimburse, the payroll cost on it, and any management tool for personal devices.
Then add the things that don’t show on a bill. The NCSC gives one aim of BYOD as reducing overheads for the organisation in terms of procurement and provisioning of corporate devices, which is the saving. Against that sit the extra support for mixed devices, the time spent when someone leaves and the risk if a personal phone is lost with client data on it.
Some firms settle on a mix: company phones for staff who handle customer data or need to be reachable on a business number, and BYOD for occasional users. Whatever you pick, write it down so everyone knows the rules.
If you go the company phones route, our guide to mobile plans for small businesses weighs SIM only against handsets, and our guide to running multiple business mobiles covers growing teams. Buying handsets for staff? See refurbished business phones vs new.
Frequently asked questions about company phones and BYOD
- Is a company phone a taxable benefit?
- Not if you provide one phone or SIM per employee and the contract is between your business and the supplier, according to HMRC. Extra phones, salary sacrifice and some other set ups are treated differently.
- Can I pay towards an employee’s own phone bill tax free?
- HMRC says reimbursing a monthly tariff or private calls over the tariff’s limit means deducting tax and National Insurance. Business calls over the limit can be reimbursed without either.
- What does BYOD stand for?
- Bring your own device: staff using their own phones, tablets or laptops for work.
- Who owns the data on a BYOD phone?
- The NCSC says the organisation owns the corporate data and resources, while the device itself is the property of the user.
Sources
- GOV.UK, Expenses and benefits: mobile phones, including the What’s exempt and What to report and pay sections. Read 18 November 2026. Source for every tax and reporting rule in this guide. No date shown on the page.
- National Cyber Security Centre, Bring your own device (BYOD). Reviewed 13 May 2025, version 2.1. Source for the BYOD definition, aims, challenges, shadow IT warning and intended audience.
Checked 18 November 2026.




