Switch broadband or haggle? What Which? found
If your broadband deal has ended and you have not touched it since, Which? has some news you will like. Its new survey, published on 20 November 2026, says people who switch broadband at the end of a contract were more likely to cut their bill than people who stayed and haggled.
Which? asked more than 5,000 customers whose broadband, broadband and TV, or mobile contract had ended in the last 12 months what they did next, and how much they saved. Of the broadband customers who chose to switch, 79% made a saving. Of those who haggled, 56% did.
Haggling still works for plenty of people. But if you want the better odds, the survey points one way: switch broadband when your contract ends.
How much did people save when they switch broadband?
Across all providers, broadband customers who switched saved around £106 a year on average. For broadband and TV customers who switched, the average was around £171. It depends heavily on who you are leaving. Which? broke the average annual saving down by the provider people switched away from, and the gap between the top and bottom of the table is large.
These are the averages Which? reports for broadband-only customers who switched provider. They are averages from a survey, not a promise of what you will save:
- Leaving BT: around £162 a year on average
- Leaving Virgin Media: around £149
- Leaving EE: around £126
- Leaving Sky: around £103
- Leaving Vodafone: around £80
- Leaving TalkTalk: around £40
- Leaving Plusnet: around £33
Which? does not promise anyone those figures, and neither do we. Your own saving will depend on what you pay now, what is available at your address and the deal you move to.
What about haggling instead?
Haggling means calling or chatting to your provider and asking for a better price to stay. Which? found it saved broadband customers less on average, but it is not nothing:
- Virgin Media customers who haggled: around £60 a year on average
- BT: around £59
- Sky: around £56
- Vodafone: around £51
- EE: around £44
- TalkTalk: around £37
- Plusnet: around £21
Across all providers, broadband customers who haggled saved around £50 a year on average, roughly half what switchers saved.
Which? also makes the point that a good haggle is not always a lower bill. Keeping the same price, or paying a little more for an upgraded package, can count as a win. If you are happy with your service and the connection is solid, that is a perfectly sensible result.
The catch is the odds. Just over half of the broadband customers who haggled saved money. Nearly four in five who chose to switch broadband did.
Is it hard to switch broadband now?
Not really, and that is the part most people get wrong. Which? found 84% of broadband customers who switched said it was easy.
The reason is One Touch Switch, which Ofcom brought in so you only deal with the new provider. According to Ofcom’s switching guide, you contact the provider you want to join and they manage the switch for you. Your old provider must not charge you for any notice period after the switchover date.
Ofcom also says any loss of service during the move should not last longer than one working day. If it does, or if a provider misses a confirmed installation appointment, you may be due automatic compensation.
So the old picture of a long phone call with a retentions team, a gap with no internet and a bill for a month you did not use is out of date. Many people still stay put because they think switching is a hassle.
Before you switch broadband
- Check whether you are still in contract. Leaving early can mean exit fees, and Ofcom says your provider must tell you about any charges before you switch.
- Note your current monthly price, so you can compare like for like.
- Check what happens to any email address your provider gave you.
- If your broadband comes with TV, you may need to cancel the TV part with your old provider yourself.
Should you haggle first, then switch?
A sensible order for most households is to look first, then decide. Find out what new customers are being offered in your area, then you know what a fair price looks like before you speak to anyone.
If your current provider can match it and you like the service, staying is fine. If it cannot, or will not, you have your answer and can switch broadband with the new deal already in hand. Which?’s own advice is to have cheaper deals ready to quote, stay polite, and ask for the retentions team if the first person cannot help.
Timing matters too. The best moment is when your fixed term has ended, because you can leave without an exit fee. Put the date your contract ends in your calendar now, so it cannot quietly slip past while you are busy with everything else. With Black Friday on 27 November, there are plenty of new customer offers around to compare against.
If you want the background on the process, our guide to One Touch Switch walks through each step. To work out whether you are paying too much in the first place, see how to tell if your broadband cost is too high.
Frequently asked questions about how to switch broadband
- Who do I contact to switch broadband?
- The provider you want to join. Under One Touch Switch it manages the switch for you, according to Ofcom.
- Will I lose my internet when I switch broadband?
- Ofcom says any loss of service should not last longer than one working day, and you may be due compensation if it does.
- Can I switch broadband if I am still in contract?
- Yes, but you may have to pay early termination charges. Ofcom says your provider must tell you about any charges before you switch.
- Is haggling worth trying?
- It can be. In the Which? survey, 56% of broadband customers who haggled saved money, against 79% of those who switched.
Sources
- Which?, How to save hundreds on mobile, broadband and TV by switching or haggling, dated 20 November 2026 on the page. Survey figures, the 84% ease figure and the haggling tips.
- Ofcom, Switching broadband provider. One Touch Switch steps, the notice period rule, the one working day limit and automatic compensation.
Checked 20 November 2026.




