Heating on all day: the verdict that never was
You’ve probably seen the headlines. Martin Lewis has “settled the debate” on leaving the heating on all day, apparently, more times this past week than anyone could count.
There’s one snag. MoneySavingExpert, the site he founded, says he hasn’t. Its energy myths guide, updated on 10 November 2026, asks readers to “ignore clickbait publications erroneously crediting Martin with an answer”, and says the question has no definitive answer.
So what do we actually know? More than nothing, as it happens. The answer depends on what’s heating your home, and the people who study this for a living are fairly clear about which way each system leans.
Is it cheaper to leave the heating on all day?
For most homes with a gas boiler, no. The Energy Saving Trust puts it bluntly: if you have a boiler, then no, because “keeping your heating on all the time will use more energy and cost you more money”. It’s better for your bills to have the boiler come on when you need it.
The logic is simple enough. A warm house leaks heat into a cold street every hour it’s warm. Keep the heating on all day and you’re paying to replace that lost heat all day, including the hours when nobody’s in.
That’s the right starting point for most people. It is not, as MoneySavingExpert points out, the end of the argument.
When does heating on all day make sense?
If you have a heat pump, the advice flips. The Energy Saving Trust says that with a heat pump “you can save money by leaving the heating on all day”.
MoneySavingExpert also reports a second view, from the heating advice firm Heat Geek. It argues that a modern condensing boiler, meaning one installed since 2005, can run more efficiently “low and slow”: a steady 18 or 19°C with the flow temperature as low as you can safely set it, instead of bursts of full heat.
That comes with conditions. According to the guide, Heat Geek’s case is strongest if you’re home all evening and at weekends, and your home has cavity wall and loft insulation up to modern standards.
| Your situation | Which way it leans | Who says so |
|---|---|---|
| Gas boiler, out most of the day | Timed heating | Energy Saving Trust |
| Heat pump | Leave it running | Energy Saving Trust |
| Modern condensing boiler, home a lot, well insulated | Low and steady may be worth testing | Heat Geek, as reported by MoneySavingExpert |
| Older brick home | Slower to warm, but releases heat back, so steady heat may suit it | Heat Geek, as reported by MoneySavingExpert |
| Underfloor heating | Better suited to constant heat than radiators | Heat Geek, as reported by MoneySavingExpert |
None of this is a promise that heating on all day will cost you more, or less. It’s a guide to where to start, and the two sources don’t fully agree on boilers.
How to find out what works in your home
MoneySavingExpert’s own conclusion is refreshingly modest: experiment. To test heating on all day against a timer, try a few days or a week with the heating on a constant low setting. Then try the same length of time with the heating on only as and when you need it.
Take a meter reading at the start and end of each stretch and compare the two. A smart meter display makes this easier, but a pen and the back of an envelope works just as well.
The catch is the weather. A mild week against a freezing one will skew the results, as the guide points out, so pick two spells that feel about the same.
Settings worth getting right either way
- Set the thermostat between 18 and 21°C. The Energy Saving Trust says that balances comfort and cost.
- With a boiler, have the heating come on around half an hour before you get up and go off around half an hour before bed.
- Close the doors of rooms you aren’t heating.
- If you’re away in winter, don’t switch it off completely. MoneySavingExpert gives a minimum of 12°C to protect pipes, notes that some say at least 15°C, and says to check your home insurance policy before you go.
The Energy Saving Trust also puts a number on one easy change. Turning the thermostat down from 22°C to 21°C could save £120 a year in Great Britain and £80 in Northern Ireland, on its figures. Your own saving depends on your home and how you heat it.
What about heating just one room?
This is the other question hiding inside the heating on all day debate. If only one person is home, heating the whole house for them is an expensive habit.
MoneySavingExpert’s sums are worth a look. On its own figures, a typical 2,000 watt electric heater costs about 53p an hour to run at October price cap rates. A typical 24 kilowatt gas boiler and radiator system running continuously at full output would cost about £1.91 an hour in gas.
That isn’t a like for like comparison, and the guide says so. A plug in heater warms one room briefly. For several rooms, or one room for hours, central heating is likely to be the more efficient choice.
The bit that matters more than the timer
The heating on all day row tends to skip one thing. How you run the heating changes how many units you use. What you pay for each unit is a separate matter, and it’s the one your supplier would rather you didn’t think about.
If you’ve been on a standard variable tariff for a while, the price you pay per unit moves whenever the price cap does. Fiddling with the timer while ignoring the tariff is a bit like turning off lights to afford a taxi.
Our guide on when to turn the heating on covers the seasonal side, and we’ve looked at why people don’t switch energy even when it would help. If draughts are the real problem, cheap draught proofing fixes will do more than any thermostat trick.
Checking what else is out there takes about a minute, and Roo’s happy to do the digging.
Frequently asked questions about heating on all day
- Did Martin Lewis say to leave the heating on all day?
- MoneySavingExpert says no. Its guide, updated on 10 November 2026, says the question has no definitive answer and asks readers to ignore clickbait publications crediting him with one.
- Is heating on all day cheaper with a gas boiler?
- The Energy Saving Trust says no. With a boiler, keeping the heating on all the time uses more energy and costs more than timing it.
- Should a heat pump be left on all day?
- The Energy Saving Trust says that with a heat pump you can save money by leaving the heating on all day.
- What temperature should the thermostat be?
- The Energy Saving Trust suggests between 18 and 21°C. If anyone at home is older or has a medical condition, comfort and health come first.
Sources
- MoneySavingExpert: Common energy myths solved, by Andrew Capstick, Updated 10 November 2026. Used for its statement on Martin Lewis, the Heat Geek view and its conditions, the meter reading test, the 12°C and 15°C minimums and the running cost figures, which are MoneySavingExpert’s own.
- Energy Saving Trust: When should I put my heating on?, Last updated: 28 September 2026. Used for the boiler and heat pump advice, the 18 to 21°C range, the timings and the £120 and £80 thermostat saving estimate.
- Heat Geek: Should Your Heating be Left on All the Time or Not?, published March 4, 2022. A heating installer’s article and the source MoneySavingExpert links to for the “low and slow” view. We’ve used MoneySavingExpert’s summary of it.
Checked 16 November 2026.




